[mythtv-users] MythTv 0.23 recording resolution and playback issues
nick.rout at gmail.com
Fri May 21 08:11:36 UTC 2010
On Thu, May 20, 2010 at 2:22 AM, Raymond Wagner <raymond at wagnerrp.com> wrote:
> On 5/19/2010 08:18, Ebsen, Mike P. wrote:
> The 10.04 release seems to always record at 1920x1080 resolution independent
> of the broadcaster’s source format. Old TV shows, like Hogan’s Heros, that
> are still being broadcasted at a very grainy 548x480 are small fields of
> video information with large black unused bands on top, bottom, left and
> right edges of the 1920x1080 *.mpg recorded file.
> Your 2250 is a digital tuner. The recordings it makes are /exactly/ what is
> being broadcast. MythTV is not altering the stream in any manner. If you
> plug in a QAM-capable TV, you will see the exact same thing.
> Another detriment of the 10.04 resolution issue is recorded file sizes.
> Recording the same program on the 9.10 and 10.04 with the same quality
> setting (Normal) results in drastically different file sizes. The older
> 9.10 release could record an old TV show at a data rate of 780 MByte/half
> hour. The latest 10.04 release records the same show at a rate of 3.3
> GByte/half hour (and a whole bunch of dark pixels surrounding the relatively
> small image in the middle).
> The quality settings on a digital tuner do absolutely nothing. MythTV will
> store the stream exactly as it is received, and will do no additional
> I thought one of the attributes of the latest 10.04 release was the newest
> H.264 codecs that were both faster and more efficient at video compression.
> My observations don’t align with these assumptions.
> MythTV does not use H.264 for video compression. It can only use MJPEG and
> ASP, and then only for analog framegrabbers. The claim was that a sync of
> the internal ffmpeg library prior to the release of 0.23 brought a better
> optimized H.264 video decompressor, that is roughly 15% faster than before.
> This is irrelevant because everything you ever record off that 2250 will be
Why? The broadcaster may transmit h.264, in which case your assumption
is out the window.
Also the HVR 2250 is analogue and digital - so your other assumption is flawed.
More information about the mythtv-users