[mythtv-users] Several inputs

[Phil Bridges]

On Wed, Feb 20, 2013 at 1:13 PM, Michael T. Dean <mtdean at thirdcontact.com>wrote:

> On 02/20/2013 11:55 AM, Phil Bridges wrote:
>
>> On Wed, Feb 20, 2013 at 11:52 AM, Michael T. Dean wrote:
>>
>>> On 02/20/2013 11:10 AM, Chris Dennis wrote:
>>>
>>>> On 19/02/13 13:23, Michael T. Dean wrote:
>>>>
>>>>> ...Note that changing the call sign will make that
>>>>> channel "different" for the purposes of "this channel" recording rules.
>>>>> However, you probably shouldn't be using "this channel" rules, anyway,
>>>>> so...
>>>>>
>>>> Why not?
>>>>
>>> Because if you want to watch a show, you shouldn't care which channel you
>>> record it from.  If you're using "this channel" rules, it's almost
>>> definitely as a hack rather than specifying what you really want.
>>>
>>> If you want only the new episodes, use a new episode filter or teach
>>> MythTV which old episodes you've seen (by marking them as Never Record).
>>>
>>> If you want only HDTV episodes, use an HDTV filter.
>>>
>>> (and so on).
>>>
>>> If you never want to record off the SDTV version of a channel for which
>>> you also have the HDTV version, why even configure the SDTV channel?
>>>
>> Just to play devil's advocate:
>>
>>
>> My daughter likes to watch some PBS shows, which show on both PBS HD
>> channels, but also show on the SD PBS-Knowledge subchannel.  Often, the HD
>> channel versions are in HD, but aren't listed as such.  I don't want to
>> record the versions on the known-SD-only channel, but I also don't want to
>> not ever watch that channel.  What is the recommended way to record from
>> both the HD channels in this scenario?
>>
>
> Well, in the event your listings don't provide the right information,
> you'll have to use a hack.
>
> However, a "this channel" rule will only allow you to record from one of
> the 2 channels.  That means you'd either have to make 2 "this channel"
> rules (which would be about as ugly a hack as you could get--since they're
> otherwise identical) or use something else--i.e. in this case, I'd
> recommend a custom rule that specifies which channels (or channel group) to
> use, or which to exclude.
>
> Channel priorities wouldn't be ideal because they'd affect how every show
> that airs on the channel compares to other shows on other channels, and
> could cause you to miss shows you want while recording shows you care less
> about.  (Well, that's true until 0.27(? I think it's going to be in the
> next version), when channel priorities become what users actually think
> they are.)
>
>
>
Yup - that's what I've had to do.  Unfortunately, that means that I have to
also manage two groups of max recordings, but that's no big deal.

Channel priorities still wouldn't help, because the SD subchannel runs
programs at different times (and more frequently) than the HD channels.
-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://www.mythtv.org/pipermail/mythtv-users/attachments/20130220/35fd8bb5/attachment-0001.html>